Chosen By: Dean
Comments -
Stu: On my fifth listen now, really getting in to this record! Favourite track to date is track 2, My Friend”s An Entomologist, I love it’s lyrics and the way it builds and the little different guitar licks throughout over a throbbing bass and simple motorik drumbeat! Fantastic! Track 4 has Blondie all over it and is proud to be called Rapture! Audacious in a great way! Anyone channeling Debbie Harry has my heart ❤️ Loving ‘Does He Want To Be A Weatherman’. Simplistically wonderful ❤️❤️ and all neatly packed in to 34 mins!! No tracks to skip, they all offer something to burrow in to your eardrum. Good use of 3 minutes on every track. The first track initially gave me reservations BUT then track 2 kicked me in the head and I was hooked! Should have been track one, note to band on track llisting. Great choice Dean and perfectly sums up your musical taste. ⭐️
Dean: Really enjoyed Sweeping Promises. Quite a revelation really. I had some time over the summer to search for some new musical inspiration and I managed to find some refreshing music in genres I had neglected. I even downloaded their previous albums and they are also impressive.
That voice is fascinating, enriched by a playful virtuosity those guitars deliver. Like the experience of listening to the Strokes for the first time. Lyrics are original and fascinating. Riffs are constantly interesting without being repetitive. It is a vehicle that can inspire great change if they were to tackle themes that might be more relevant. It's a politically motivated band with the talent to convert or shape opinion. At this moment in time the theme of marginalisation is poignant but the potential they possess should they realise it, is vast.π
Paul: There's a lot to like here. And, as mentioned in passing, I'm on the same page as Stu for a lot of it. I don't think it's the best choice of an opening track, My Friend's an Entomologist is probably my favourite and Rapture is the most Blondie thing I've heard post-Blondie. It's unashamedly post-punk and some of the bass lines are straight out of the Fall playbook.
And I wonder if that's why I don't love it like I should. Not all the tracks grab me like those mentioned above and what is there isn't bringing much, if anything, new to the party. Maybe I'm being too hard on it. The high points are very high and as Dean says the potential is there but overall I can't quite give it a star.
Ben: I used AI to generate these words but it includes what I think about the record quite nicely….
Sweeping Promises return with You Say I Romanticize, a record bursting with their signature frenetic art-punk energy and jagged, lo-fi charm. Instrumentally, the duo is in top form; the overall sound is delightfully urgent and raw. The undisputed highlight of the album is the propulsive, melodic basslines, which anchor the tracks with real ballast. The standout track "Accent" boasts a killer, spiky bass groove that demands your attention. However, the vocals prove a bit divisive this time around. While the sharper, frantic deliveries fit the aesthetic perfectly, the vocal performance falters on sustained notes, occasionally sounding strained and overly exposed in the mix.